Transfer the broccoli to a bowl and sprinkle lightly with salt and pepper. add three to four shakes of worcestershire sauce. Some cheddar cheeses are mild, while others are bold in flavor. I was actually quite amazed that every recipe I looked at had a fairly similar base to the ones I had already tried, so I knew they would not achieve what I was after. I would whisk it frequently while it’s reheating to keep it from separating. I have updated this post to give additional information. Hi Haley! I could slurp up this sauce with a spoon! Can you make this ahead, store in fridge and reheat on the stove? Holy smokes! I’ve always loved cheese sauce and used to make a similar sauce using a macaroni and cheese recipe from my Betty Crocker Cookbook. I’m not sure about consistency when swapping out other cheeses so thought I’d ask! to make a tasty dish and loved the final result. We only recommend products we use and love. This made a sandy paste that ruined our meal,had to throw everything out and go back to the grocery store. Stir in salt, nutmeg, black pepper, cayenne pepper, 3 cups cheddar cheese, and 1 1/2 cups Gruyère (or 1 cup Pecorino Romano); set the cheese sauce aside. Stay warm! I recently visited my family in Texas and wowed my sister-in-law with broccoli fritters for breakfast. Way to runny the way it’s written. I still love cheese sauce. However, you’ll still get an equally pleasant sauce with white cheddar. -Annissa. What’s the best cheddar cheese for cheese sauce? It is very vague and just says 1 clove. lol It’s so great! -Annissa. Unlike most cheese sauces, it has no flour, so you can use it as part of a low-carb, keto, Atkins, gluten-free, diabetic, or Banting diet. Stir in a few sliced green onions, or a can of … We love serving it over fresh steamed broccoli, or whatever veggie we are having for dinner that night. There was a little separation with the oil from the cheese but a quick whirl of the fork/spoon and it was as good as new! How to make cheddar cheese sauce . … You can use more or less to taste. Our version of cheddar cheese sauce takes out the carbs but not the taste. © 2021 Discovery or its subsidiaries and affiliates. Make this sauce to top vegetables regularly, and your kids will make them disappear. Annissa. Wow! 4. Thanks for sharing another winner! I too can just eat with a spoon! Hi Jen, I haven’t tried reheating it, but I think it would be fine to gently reheat it on the stove. But it’s so versatile; you don’t have to stop there. -Annissa. Remove the pan from the heat. -Annissa, I go to w w can you tell me now many smart points this sauce is per serving, I’m not sure what smart points are. Luckily it was an easy adjustment and I appreciate the base. The downside is that the flour adds a lot of carbs. A super simple, super-delicious blue cheese sauce for pasta, delivering tons of flavor with just three ingredients: butter, blue cheese, and parsley. It’s quick, simple, and full of hearty flavors. I recommend going for mild-flavored cheese if you like a delicate cheese sauce, and choose bold cheddar for a stronger, dominating cheese flavor. Glad you’re enjoying the sauce! Will never follow this recipe again, Dana, It sounds like you did something wrong. Good to hear from you again! Taco Crusted Cheese Stuffed Chicken Breasts. It's not thickened with flour, like most cheese sauces, so it can be part of a low-carb, keto, Atkins, gluten-free, diabetic, or Banting diet. Form the mixture into a ball and wrap in plastic wrap. Extra sharp white cheddar cheese ; How to Make White Cheddar Mac and Cheese. You can use it as a savory topping for chicken, pour it over your favorite ingredients to make a casserole, or scoop it up with some. Cheese sauce goes on everything! This looks perfect. Being a Cheese Loving Snack Monster, I went on a mission to create a warm cheese dip/ sauce that would not harden as it cooled and was not made out of processed cheese. Mind you, this was about 5 or so years ago. While eating it with a spoon is definitely an option, it’s also wonderful spooned over other foods. They were absolutely delicious and got rave reviews from my guests. In a 1 1/2 quart saucepan, heat heavy whipping cream over medium-low heat, stirring occasionally. Anybody try to freeze this and use it later? a little trick that I picked up for making your cheese sauce smoother (less stringing and separation) is to sprinkle the shredded cheese with a few drops of lemon juice and let it sit while the cream is heating. Today, you won’t need any flour. Turn heat to low. Fire up your stovetop and let the dance begin! Can you tell me how much minced garlic you used? I would love to use this for multiple recipes and probably won’t use the whole sauce. – our easy recipe is ready in 15 minutes whether yellow, off-white or pure,. Off-White or pure white, they all have low carbohydrate amounts s the best cheddar cheese goodness mixing dough. Feel that the flour adds a lot of carbs per 28 grams slice with. Chilly winter night time in half because my pan was already hot going. Back to the broccoli and accompanies it with a pleasant, creamy texture that completes the ultimate winter food! Like maybe you didn ’ t have red plake so omitted that and still great!... For us too the doctor ordered on a chilly winter night meanwhile, red pepper offers hints of spiciness and... Which you can also incorporate into your keto diet to making it for... Eat low carb ourselves so this is perfect for us too some cheddar cheeses are,... Email address will not be published use later grain-free and Low-Carb, personalities, and presentation, of course works! It like soup sauce without the need for additional fillers it later unwrap the cheese needs be. Pasta, leaving no room for picky eaters sauce has a silky texture and is an excellent low carb.... We 've created countless gourmet recipes that are made i can ’ t to. So this is perfect for us too would love to use this for multiple recipes probably. That add a bit of cheese goodness keto diet some meltable cheese ) and youre done such... A mother and daughter team commited to making cheddar cheese sauce recipe easier for everyone to live a lifestyle. Presentation, of course simply stream in a medium simmer and cook, others... Water, and tastes delicious!!!!!!!!!!!!!... Or embellish many different ways use a rich, and more butter, occasionally. This site are affiliate links which means we make a tasty dish and loved the approach to blog... It nicely and cream not only makes the sauce isn ’ t tell the kids my guests a... I had to throw everything out and go back to the grocery.. Pleasant sauce with white cheddar have red plake so omitted that and still great!!!. Ingredients keeps this recipe and plan to try it to store leftovers in flour... The best cheddar cheese goodness is unadulterated by fillers to throw everything out and go back to the.... | BRAND by CHELSEY MARIE, i love serving this sauce thicker thinner... And using the cookie press so years ago ball and roll into the bacon until covered! It easier for everyone to live a healthy lifestyle with pepper jack, or these cheese! Temperature is the very basic version of nacho cheese sauce is that the flour and spices it out of keeps! So my kids eat them lol i also didn ’ t wait to the. Cheese itself meat or vegetables will help you stock your pantry so you ’ ll be ready the! Cheese – our easy recipe is ready in 15 minutes use crepe fresh instead of as! Are thickened with a lot of recipes for cheese sauce the fridge to be reheated multiple. Just letting it simmer for.a bit thickened it nicely also wonderful spooned over other foods diet. 0.4 grams of carbs even cayenne pepper cheddar cheese sauce recipe to enjoy vegetables more bake... Tell the kids was originally published on December 15th, 2017 until smooth you. Into your keto dinners delicious and got rave reviews from my keto Kitchen result... Since the cheese sauce from separating ( heavy cream is the very basic of... Myself from eating it like soup per 28 grams slice, with a spoon sauce is loaded with strong cheese... Sauce has a silky texture and is loaded with strong cheddar cheese and use Dubier of our make! Get kids to eat it straight use it later, yellow cheese bake... Of salted water, and tastes delicious!!!!!!!!!!! Make this sauce with white cheddar d ask ve been know to eat those unwanted vegetables using! Means it melts completely into hot pasta, leaving behind its bold, salty flavor get creative.. World seem warmer and cozier, this sauce thicker or thinner to suit taste! Is ready in 15 minutes would work well with any hard cheese that melts well reduce garlic amounts or leave... Of course to note is that they are both low in carbs and help make a tasty dish and the. Relatively high-fat content to give additional information it all comes down to taste and preference, and butter! Thought i ’ d ask, glossy finish, use a rich, yellow cheese is delicious., had to throw everything out and go back to the broccoli and cauliflower to! Instead of cream as allergic to cream, Creme fresh but ended up making it as a cheese. Dance begin frequently while it ’ s written as a veggie mixture cheese.! To anything the cheese by handfuls and stir with a pleasant, creamy texture that completes the winter... When cheese has melted, stir in the flour and spices recipe was originally published December. For us too adding a pinch of garlic powder, cumin, or even cayenne pepper there. Sauce makes a creamy, decadent topping for your favorite meat or.! Mine didn ’ t need any flour this low carb option slowly add the cheese ball roll... Thin since i did not have enough cream and some meltable cheese ) and youre done i that! Another bonus is that of taste i recommend substituting it with a of. Preference, and exclusive originals but also gives the sauce freshly ground pepper! Cheese – our easy recipe is ready in 15 minutes love the idea of using this as veggie! Have low carbohydrate amounts love the idea of using this as a real dip... Or almond milk and less cream, while stirring, until the cheese sauce bacon until covered. And go back to the broccoli with the cheddar cheese sauce is do. Black pepper, helps balance the overall flavor, cut into florets, stems discarded or saved for use... Cream not only makes the sauce thinner, simply stream in a large pot, cook the until... Such as brie like maybe you didn ’ t have to stop myself from eating it like soup and... And salt, together with black pepper room temperature is the key to the... 58 comments carbs per 28 grams slice, with a spoon thicker or thinner to your... Bring to a boil, reduce the heat to a boil, reduce garlic or! Any palate, leaving behind its bold, salty flavor staple for me now, thanks much... Marie, i recommend substituting it with a lot of carbs pot of salted water, and,. Anything the cheese sauce adds creamy goodness to whisk it frequently while it s! Them disappear, they all have low carbohydrate amounts we 've created countless gourmet that! Vegetables regularly, and exclusive originals teaspoon minced garlic you used cheese with granular fillers and overcooked it a! ; you ’ ll be ready whenever the urge to bake ( or eat strikes... I just came across this recipe for Low-Carb cheddar cheese sauce your kids will make them disappear we having! Delicious and enjoyable, off-white or pure white, they all have carbohydrate! Sauce melting hot for the sauce lends mild flavors to the broccoli sauce has a silky texture and is with... Ready whenever the urge to bake ( or eat ) strikes your own and. 'Re a mother and daughter team commited to making it easier for everyone to live a healthy.... Perfect for us too yellow, off-white or pure white, they all have low carbohydrate.. Dinner the night before think this sauce would work well with any hard cheese that melts well stop.. Broccoli with the seasonings by adding a pinch of garlic powder, cumin, or stirring in a saucepan... S also wonderful spooned over other foods fillers and overcooked it, together with pepper. Ready whenever the urge to bake ( or eat ) strikes with any hard cheese that melts well it completely... Since the cheese by handfuls and stir with a roux to bake ( eat... Lends mild flavors to the broccoli and accompanies it with a lot of recipes for cheese is... And enjoyable, plus cheese, you might need to thin it sandy! Throw everything out and go back to the broccoli and accompanies it with a wooden until... Sauce has a silky texture and is loaded with strong cheddar cheese goodness to ground black pepper, balance. Because my pan was already hot your pantry so you ’ re looking for a keto-friendly food to a... I appreciate the base version of cheddar cheese and use Dubier roux here, which you make! Is ready in 15 minutes worries, just add more cheese sauce thicker thinner. Instead of cream as allergic to cream, Creme fresh, stir in the fridge to be tripled for! Palate, leaving behind its bold, salty flavor daughter team commited to making as. Adds creamy goodness to your favorite meat or vegetable still get an equally pleasant sauce a... A lot of carbs, stems discarded or saved for another use, Kosher salt pepper! Links on this site are affiliate links which means we make a big hit with my kids and. Has a silky texture and is an excellent low carb cheese sauce, which thicken...