Thanks I recommend contacting the Assistant Editor about this issue. Pending decision This manuscript status means that the Academic Editor is assessing the peer review process. Is there anyway to revised the manuscript? Publishing times also differ depending on the journal. Alternatively, you could decide to use the credit on your next submission. - Ian Nov 17, 2017 at 6:54 Add a comment 2 Answers Sorted by: 22 "Decision pending" means that the decision. The length of the process could be dependent on the editors workload, for example, or the scope of the journal/SI. The status was pending editor decision for two weeks and then changes to pending decision. You can find their details by visiting the journal webpage and clicking Editorial Office in the left-hand column. We submitted the manuscript entitled, A Systematic Review of Deep Knowledge Graph-based Recommender Systems, with focus on Explainable Embeddings on 2022-03-22, with manuscript ID: data-1670544. However, the editors decision was reject and decline submission. Now here are on 21 June and no final decision yet, Should I be concerned about it or it is normal procedure? However, the average net cost to authors across all journals was CHF 1258 per paper. The submission ID is scipharm-2152900. As an author, this manuscript status means that its time to review your manuscript and edit it using the comments provided. This article already published in online. It will soon be published online! Final Decision to accept or reject my paper, is it based purely on the Review Report of Additional Reviewers (Round 2) only? But if go through the link the editorial decision is showing rejected and redeclined submission. I and a few of my connections from the USA have submitted valuable papers using the voucher code they got during reviewing process. The paper has been edited by a native English Editor. Authorship details are added during the initial submission, and all co-authors should double-check the initial manuscript. second, can we re-submit on the same journal as Energies if the editor suggests to withdraw? I am afraid we spent a lot of time on review. Traditional journals nowadays take really long time to review, while MDPI can guarantee the speed. Apart from contacting the Editorial Office, support is readily available at support@mdpi.com. Unfortunately, we cannot help from the blog in that regard, but we can recommend you to contact the publishing manager of Sustainability, Ms Neda Nikolic (nikolic@mdpi.com). Thank you very much! Therefore, we received positive comments from three reviewers in the first and the second revision round. During the review process I have add one new author and replace the other one. Hi Katherine Now our paper is accepted, but as I ask from the Section Managing Editor about the author addition. The IOAP entitles authors to a 10% discount on APCs. Please contact the Editorial Office if it has been five business days and an Assistant Editor has not yet been assigned to your submission. However, there is no guarantee that your work will be accepted for publication. You can find their details on the journals webpage, by clicking on Editorial Office on the left-hand navigation menu. You can simply email them back, in the same thread where they provided you with the first proofreading. Most of our journals suggest 5 days for minor revisions and 1014 days for major revisions. Please accept the editors changes before updating the manuscript. 2- Did I receive email if the current status change to Pending major or miner. Pending major or minor revisions = Author revisions are in progress. Please could you reach out to the journals Editorial Office? This is usually completed within 24 hours. This will reduce any potential delays. can I ask for payment extension of the apc? One month ago, I have submitted the Manuscript to Polymers Journal. Although some papers pass through the process and hit all the time estimates, others may take longer, for many different reasons. so how to upload the revised proposed paper? I will keep in contact with you via email. You can find more information about MDPI manuscript statuses in our handy blog article. If you still dont notice any updates, please get back in touch. It could be that the Managing Editor needs to re-assess some of the details. I submitted my manuscript to the journal of Materials (materials-2126601) on December 13th. They usually have a busy schedule. My article was in pending conversation but now status shows that conversation skipped what does it mean? I have contacted the personal editor, but she did not reply me about this question. Later my submission went to the Chief Editors Final Decision. The deadline would be midnight at the end of that day. Im concerned since its been 25 days and I havent heard a response from the journal side or from my assigned editor side. You can expect to receive information about changes soon. How can any one expect novelty in a survey study of this kind. Status Associate Editor .Review process , 3 . This is very surprising to hear. MDPI has a name change policy for after publication. I would like to inquire about the status of my manuscript that has been under review since the 21st of November 2022 [Cells] Manuscript ID: cells-2079368. I have submitted manuscript to Animals on 1st of September and I received reject and encourage resubmittion. We have reached out to the editorial office on your behalf. Thus, we would be glad for any information concerning this manuscript. MDPI prides itself on the high speed and flexibility of its publication. Please forward our message to the senior members and discuss our issue to solve this problem on time. Mdpi . Your paper is actually going through an open peer review. Thank you very much for answering my previous comment. how long would it takes to review. You can find contact details on the journal webpage. Hi, one of my paper was submitted in Sustainability and its status is pending decision for last 4 days, although review reports are showing up. The status changed from Pending review to Under review on January 5th and the Assistant Editor was also assigned on that day. I have a concern regarding MDPi policies. No need to worry. Hi, You should improve your manuscript based on the feedback provided by the reviewers. The status Revised version review indicates that your paper has been sent for a second round of reviews. If the journal cannot accept addition of new author, so they should tell us the reason. Whether this is invoiced to the institution directly or the author will depend on which institution it is. In fact, in 2022, the average waiver rate across all MDPI journals was 35%. Will my abstract be posted in the same way or will the editors remove it before making it public? I submitted my manuscript for the Diagnostic Journal Under Special Issues / Applications of AI in ECG on Oct 20,2022. Hi Since the first day of the submission, we have tried to contact the editorial office along with the Handling Editor, requesting them to assist us in applying the discount vouchers we have obtained from performing peer-review. Hi Thanks for reading. Usually, the Handling Editor would help us after we provided them with the details. Please reach out to the Editorial Office if anything there is unclear. My sincere apologies that you have been waiting so long. This stage might take longer than 1-2 business days, depending on the Academic Editors workload. I would greatly appreciate it if you can help us with this matter. I Hope you are well. As part of our service, an in-house Assistant Editor is assigned to each manuscript. This is a mandatory step with no additional fee. Its unusual that they wouldnt get back to you let me follow this up for you. During this stage, we are looking for expert reviewers in the field, and waiting for them to review the manuscript. We wanted to remove and add authors. Whether my work is it Good or Bad? I am getting worried about the delay. I encourage you to take a look at the Under review section in this article. what is the chance for publication ? Apologies for the delay. Hello. Is it normal to wait for such a long time. So, they directly refused that we will not consider the new author. Or should we just wait? In general, social sciences journals have slightly more time-consuming publishing processes than natural sciences journals. We submitted the minor revision (second round) on 13th January 2023 but still it is showing Pending editor decision. Thanks and regards. Here is a short video on manuscript status in Editorial Manager, and some additional articles on the manuscript submission process. Pending review = The paper is due to be pre-checked. Id encourage you to get in touch with the Editorial Office soon to make this happen. Any delays from us are extremely short, allowing MDPI to maintain high publishing speeds. MDPI journals all have a stringent peer review process to ensure the novelty and scientific accuracy of manuscripts. Congrats! At MDPI, we want to ensure that the submission process runs as smoothly as possible for our authors. There is no set percentage with regard to what is acceptable and what is not. I want to ask what does it mean editor comment lauout with pending editor descion from last ten days. This is highly unusual and I am following this up on your behalf. [1] 21 . Hope this helps. However, we have not been receiving any response. But, Im happy to inform you that, as your colleague is part of an IOAP institute, the APC will be discounted. The Editors evaluate the suitability of . However, MDPI carries out most of the publishing steps, from submission to online publication. Moreover, it significantly contributes to knowledge and guides dentists to evidence based recommendations in the practice. You can find out about the journals scope in the Aims & Scope section, which can be accessed via the journal menu, or by searching for individual Special Issue webpages. For Instance I am not a IOAP institue author, but one of my co-author is correspondent to IOAP institute, and the payment mode for his/her IOAP institute is centralised to the university. I submitted the manuscript 6 days ago but still, but it is showing Pending Review Ive read that pending review takes around a few days and I should contact you if it takes more than 5 days. I submitted paper to agriculture journal number of article is 1972147 and I finished two rounds of major revisions. If the status says xml2pdf done after that how much time it takes for online publication of article ?? In this article, we will first discuss the overall publishing process, and then describe each manuscript status in detail. Is it possible. Your paper should currently appear as a PDF online. We always try to provide a decision as soon as possible, but we rely on external academic editors for that. Hi, mdpi publication . The Assistant Editor will also ensure that reports are collected as agreed and will inform authors if any delays are expected. A final decision is now being made about your paper. I would like to know the status of our manuscript Cells-2139714. Hi there Syed. If possible, could you help to reach editorial office on my behalf? Occasionally, they may need more time. You can find out more about the specifics by contacting the Editorial Office directly. Hi Katherine Can you please explain the editorial process for papers submitted to special issues (SIs) before reaching the under-review stage? This means that the journal might have requested a review that they . May I know what the possible reason for the delay is? Respected Madam, Could you please contact the guest editor/assistant editor on our behalf to know the problem? Not to worry. The Editorial Office can help you with this. Do I have to write the names of all authors, author affiliations, and funders in my manuscript? Hi, It will include instructions and insight related to next steps. Thank you for the comment. pending editor decisionpending611 ~ TA 1 2021-02-21 10:52 - 6 Android 2 2021-02-21 16:50 1 ~ 20 3 2021-04-21 18:52 1 4 2021-04-28 15:27 . I want to submit the manuscript to Social Science. I have tried to email the journal editor and assigned editor but has yet to receive a response. MDPI Journals A-Z Information & Guidelines Initiatives About Login Register Submit Guidelines for Reviewers Instructions for Authors . Hi, we submitted a paper in Agronomy journal almost 2 months ago. Hopefully, you will get a decision very soon. Thats an easy mistake to make. I have a quary that during Proofread i have done a mistake can I submit it again.if possible then what should be the process. However, I have not yet received a response from the editorial office. Once your paper has been accepted for publication, you cannot add or remove authors. We are sure you will get better answers and possible solutions from her. Please could you get in touch with the Agronomy Editorial Office? Warm greeting, My name is Alvian Toto Wibisono. Your work will be read and rated by a few academics from your field. For updates related to your article, please contact the editorial office of the journal that you submitted to. Hi everyone Ive submitted my paper long time ago its been two years years now since my status remains under review, what should I do at this moment Ive been trying sending an enquiries but there was know response. Ill post again after editing. On 14 Nov 2022, I could see all the R three Peer Review Reports (Round -1). I would encourage you to contact the Academic Editor for any missed updates. On February 15th, I requested to change the correspondence email address for my [Administrative Sciences] Manuscript ID: admsci-2182229. Our article is in the same status from the last 7 days. Any feedback will be helpful. This is highly unusual and can likely be quickly resolved. I am going to submit my academic paper for my PhD degree. MDPI does not offer multi-language journals, despite the importance of international contributions. Dont worry! Hi Ham, you could start by selecting the most appropriate journal from the list at https://www.mdpi.com/ and submitting your academic paper to your chosen journal. On rare occasions, the Assistant Editor assigned to your manuscript will request a further opinion from a new reviewer. What does it mean. Please contact the Assistant Editor if you require an extension. Our Micromachines paper has been Under Review for 22 days now, despite the 14.4 days review speed posted in the website. MDPIpending decisionunder reviewpending decision. Is there specific time zone for each deadline of special issues? I have replied to reviewers comments for the second time today. Please could you get in touch with the Sustainability Editorial Office for further information? Under review implies that peer review is taking place. . The different versions of your manuscript are tracked in SuSy. We have reached out to the editorial office on your behalf and you should hear back from them soon. Our paper had pending editors decision status for 8 days then the status changed to revised version review. You can find out more about our peer review process, pre-check and other policy requirements here: https://www.mdpi.com/editorial_process. Take a look at our How to navigate SuSy video for guidance. Depending on the nature of the error, a correction or erratum may be issued. Please get in touch with the journals Editorial Office, and they will update this for you. I think it is not fear that we has pass the blind review pass and now after acceptance the managing editor decided that they are not accepting our changes regarding author addition. From sharing the latest MDPI blog news, to showcasing our most popular articles, the newsletters will keep you in the loop with everything good going on in the science world. The status for my sustainability-1961792 is showing Pending editor decision since 3rd Nov 2022. Dear Torres, thank you for your comment. If the paper was rejected because it did not fall within the scope of the Special Issue, then you can resubmit to a Special Issue that is more fitting. Hi Navdeep, thanks for your comment. I have attached the files in my email to her. Should I email the Assistant Editor about it? How much time it takes in Pending editor decision? If you have questions or queries about the feedback, you can reach out to the Academic Editor assigned to your manuscript, for more details. But one reviewer gave -ve report. Yes, thats correct. The Author submits a manuscript.2. This will tell you all you need to know about this status. In most cases, the MDPI peer review process is single-blind, meaning that authors dont know who the reviewers are. Unfortunately, the paper cannot be withdrawn after acceptance. I have contacted editorial office many times but no response. Regards, It usually takes 12 days. Click on Editorial Office in the left-hand navigation bar. In addition, MDPI offers Authors Services (https://www.mdpi.com/authors/english) before paper submission. Furthermore, the reviewers then have 1-2 weeks to provide their comments. Please could you contact the Academic Editor for an update? Hi Nawal, thanks for the comment! Plagiarism is not acceptable in MDPI journals. If youre struggling with this, you can reach out to the Academic Editor assigned to your paper, who can add the vouchers before the paper is accepted. Pending decision= Academic Editor (48) Pending major or minor revisions= Pending editor decision Academic Editor Paper accepted= English correction done (24: ) Please get in touch with the journals Editorial Office if you are struggling to meet the submission deadline. The status of paper is pending decision for 33 days. Other versions of your manuscript, including HTML, will soon follow. Who can we ask for help beside assigned editor? As you have been waiting for more than a week, please could you reach out to the Assistant Editor of your manuscript? Make sure to review the rejection feedback in SuSy and apply it to your manuscript, if applicable. Dear Shams, thank you for your comment. The Horticulturae Editorial Office will be able to help you withdraw your manuscript. reject => => major revision => => pending editor decision. We have submitted on a special issue of Cells. It has been two weeks since the status Revised version review. You can do this by logging into MDPI SuSy, our online submission system. Then we revised it and submitted it on 13th of November. hello sir, i submitted a research article to applied sciences. I submitted my manuscript to the Economies on December 30th 20222. is possible to change the submission from mdpi computers to mdpi applied sciences. Our agreed reviewer time ranges from one to two weeks (depending on the journal), but we are flexible if reviewers require more time. If you find yourself waiting any longer, please do reach out to the journals Editorial Office. As we know, Metals MDPI has a high reputation for the rapid publication process. The Editorial Office has received the manuscript and it is being pre-checked. We submitted 2nd revised manuscript and status directly changed to Pending editor decision. What does its mean after proofreading submission? Please send it to the assistant editor assigned, she/he will guide you. The first round of reviews usually takes around two to three weeks. Thanks for getting in touch! This mean I reviewed your manuscript, But I want to reject?. Could you help us contacting the editorial office on our behalf. Upon completion of the production steps, the article will be available online. I can see the reviewer report is not very encouraging. You can find this feedback on SuSy, MDPIs manuscript submission system. MDPI waives around a quarter of its APCs every year and offers one of the most affordable pricing structures in the commercial publishing landscape. Still, I havent gotten any requests for minor or major changes. If you have introduced an error in the proofreading stage, it is important for you to reach out to the editorial office and the Assistant Editor who is handling your manuscript to inform them of this. The Pending review stage usually takes about five working days maximum. Manuscript status can be a little bit confusing at times. Regarding your procedure, it takes 1-2 days to display the final decision. Take a look at any feedback that may have been given on SuSy, as this will help you improve your manuscript before resubmission. MDPI joined CRediT (Contributor Roles Taxonomy) early on in the initiatives launch. They can give you the details. I would like to know the status of our manuscript jtaer-2220409 They may be able to suggest other options. The Assistant Editor aims to find reviewers within the first week of sending out invitations. Moreover, We have asked such issues to Assistant Editor and IJERPH Editorial Office multiple times via email. Dear Madam, You can get in touch with the journals Editorial Office about this request. They will be able to help you. From sharing the latest MDPI blog news, to showcasing our most popular articles, the newsletters will keep you in the loop with everything good going on in the science world. As you have been waiting for over a week, we recommend reaching out to the Assistant Editor for details. JAMS is the submission system behind MDPI's journals. You can certainly reach out to the Managing Editor and inform them of this issue. We are passionate about publishing high-quality research in all academic and scientific fields. how long of status Pending Review after submission day? This manuscript status indicates that a paper has been pre-checked and is now being peer-reviewed. Please provide the reason for your withdrawal request. In addition, all papers are available online as soon as they are published. Please I have only two question I really appreciate if I got the answer: 1- Did my status changed to Pending major or miner decision before that I dont know because I didnt check my status I guess it can take up to a month or even longer, depending on journal and field. Any pending edits or misunderstandings will be addressed via email before the paper is published to avoid post-publication edits. Under review = The paper is being peer-reviewed. You can use any number of discount vouchers from MDPI peer review. Every MPDI manuscript is converted into different formats, ready for publication. Click on Editorial Office as shown to find their contact details. The pending review stage generally takes around 1-5 working days. Can we resubmit after withdrawing the paper suggested by the editor of Energies again on the same journal as a fresh new submission? It is first time for me to face this issue in MDPI as I published a lot of papers in MDPI journals and the decision was take after 2days. I am worried about the slow process. Thank you for getting in touch. Please get in touch with the journals Editorial Office. Hi, I have submitted my manuscript on 29, September 2022. Hi, You can find the details here: https://www.mdpi.com/journal/agronomy/editorial_office. What does it mean? Many thanks for the comment. Our dedicated in-house team completes the administrative work. You could try submitting without style files. Id appreciate it if you could let me know if there has been any development on my submission. I hope to find the solution from commenting in this blog. Hope this helps! How much do I need to revise it to resubmit it to the SI? Hello Sopheap, thank you for the comment. My manuscript is (Pending a decision). If you find yourself waiting for more than a week, it's best to contact the Assistant Editor for an update. Im going to chase this up on your behalf. However, this requirement is fairly new; thus, genomic sequence information is . As for the Arxiv submission process, you can refer to their advice on this matter. Check out our article on manuscript statuses for more information. They can opt-out of open review for you. We have submitted our manuscript to Cancers and got major revision. Can the author request to change the reviewer after receiving their comments? MDPIpending decisionPending editor decision. Kindly clarify what does this indicate? This does depend on their schedules. In this case, you can add the full name in brackets after the initials. The status is still Pending Review. I have contacted with the editorial office but I did not get response. Shams. Regarding the CRediT (Contributor Roles Taxonomy), what to do if two of the co-authors have the same initials (first and last names)? Once you have reviewed this, please get in touch with the Veterinary Sciences Editorial Office. To find out more, check out our interview with MDPI English editors. I am worried if the deadline is not met. We started the submission on 30th May 2022, we received a response from reviewers on 20th June and completed the revision on 27th June 2022. The same reviewers from the first review will take another look at your manuscript. Even the editorial boards has right to accept any changes or reject but at must be logical. ? Please note that, if there are reviewer recommendations that have not been sufficiently addressed after two rounds of revisions, rejections or resubmissions may be warranted. I was wondering if the status is not getting updated due to a technical error. So, i would like to ask if there is a chance to reconfirm and revise the paper after accept. Thus, we would be glad for any information concerning this manuscript. Excuse me, if this status is Pending editor decision, how many days will it take to make a decision? They should also tell us on advance during the review stage. Please reach out to the Assistant Editor or the Editorial Office for further guidance on this matter as it will largely depend on when in the publication process you are in. The status of my paper is showing pending editorial decision. Our Editorial Office may agree to extended revision time, provided that the authors send their request to the in-house Assistant Editor. We are assuming that MDPI is like a money machine nowadays and only or mostly accepted paper without the vouchers code. MDPI6 Editor-in-Chief I want to know if this decision was made by the SI GE or others. Your paper has been published and is now being converted into PDF format. It is already more than three weeks since my manuscript was submitted, but there is still no feedback from editorial office and the status is still Under review. Check out this article on MDPIs name change policy for more information about how you can update the authors of your manuscript. As to reply back after paper submission by 2-3 days if accepted. . Reviewer 1 I also email to editorial office but they dont reply to me. Some may have other commitments, meaning that the reviews are submitted late. Thank you. Rather, it refers to the final decision by the Editor-in-Chief (EIC). On academic journal scales, 15 days is almost nothing. This manuscript status means that your manuscript has officially been accepted for publication. If you have any questions specific to your paper, please reach out to the Assistant Editor assigned to your manuscript. If it takes any longer than 24 hours, the Assistant Editor will contact you to let you know. However, if your paper has already been published, it will have to remain in open review. Apologies that you have been waiting so long. I have written to the editorial office to provide us with detailed peer review report since the status is under review. As your paper is still being processed, you can easily withdraw and re-submit the paper. What exact time are the submission forms closed on the deadline day?